Hudson logo
File #: 21-0010    Version: Name:
Type: Staff Report Status: Filed
File created: 2/5/2021 In control: City Council Workshop
On agenda: 2/23/2021 Final action: 2/23/2021
Title: Downtown Development Community Survey Proposals Brief Description: The purpose of this discussion is to review the City's Request for Proposal format, and the submitted proposals the City received for the community survey.
Indexes: Administration
Attachments: 1. City of Hudson - Community Survey Request for Proposals (RFP) 11-25-2020, 2. RAC - email/memo with Proposal (12-9-2020), 3. RAC - Survey Proposal (12-9-2020), 4. RAC - Addendum to Proposal (1-14-21), 5. BNIM - Response to RFP (12-11-2020), 6. BNIM - Fee Proposal (12-11-2020), 7. BNIM - Interview Presentation (1-11-2021)

Title

Downtown Development Community Survey Proposals

Brief Description:   The purpose of this discussion is to review the City’s Request for Proposal format, and the submitted proposals the City received for the community survey.

Body

Legislative History

Discussed at the February 9, 2021 workshop.

Purpose & Explanation

In November 2020, the City sent out Request for Proposals (RFP) to eleven (11) qualified consultants within the United States that perform similar types of survey and analysis.  The proposals were due on December 11, 2020.  The City received two (2) formal RFP for the Downtown Development Community Survey as listed below.

Following the 3-member staff review of the two proposals in December, and interviews with each consultant as to their ability to do the required work and understanding of the RFP, the City staff is recommending Research Analytics Consulting, LLC of Pittsburgh, PA. to perform the Community Survey.

The total not-to-exceed fee submitted by Research Analytics Consulting, LLC is $17,000.00.

The other consultant’s fee proposals are noted below: 

Other consultant proposals:
BNIM,  Kansas City, Missouri  $44,800.00

Unresponsive Consultants:

Goody-Clancy, Boston (They do not cover in-house)

SCB, Chicago (No Response)

Schmidt, Pittsburgh (Declined participation)

One Bridge Tech, Indianapolis (No Response)

Survey Design & Analysis, Denver (No Response)

DPZ, Miami (No Response)

Gallup, Omaha (No Response)

Usman Group, Chicago  (Declined due to current workloads.)

Precision Opinion, Las Vegas (No Response)

Legal Authority for Proposed Legislation

Pursuant to Charter Section 6.04:

       Competitively bid and advertised for three consecutive weeks.

                       Joint or Cooperative Purchase Program

 X                       Professional Services

                                              Other

Fiscal Impact

                                            Currently Budgeted

   X     Supplemental Appropriation Required

                       Appropriation Not Required

Does this legislation require use of an emergency clause?

                                            Yes

                          No

   X                       To be determined, concerning forthcoming legislation.

 

Recommendation

Suggested Action

Staff requests City Council provide direction on the Downtown Development Community Survey following the discussion of the RFP format and proposals received.

Submitted by,

Jane Howington, City Manager

Thomas J. Sheridan, Assistant City Manager - Professional Services

Jeff Knoblauch, Assistant City Manager - Finance Director

Jody Roberts, Communication Manager